InC-Student Collaboration - May 25, 2012
Attending
Michael Gettes, Carnegie Mellon
Karen Hanson, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Keith Hazelton, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Nate Klingenstein, Internet2
Mark McConahay, Indiana University
Arnie Miles, Georgetown University
Harry Nicolos, NCSU
Vince Timbers, Penn State
Ann West, Internet2/InCommon
Khalil Yazdi, Internet2
Action Items
- All to update the use case page with your campus use case. Please include your campus name in the use case so we know your specific requirements
- Ann to start documenting HE requirements
Notes
Authentication Use Cases
First Production Version: What do you need?
CMU - two use cases - Michael
- 1) applying through CommApp apply to CMU
- 2) common app id to login and obtain andrew id to get permanent credentials.
Get to campus, might up loA later. Want to eliminate confusion about how to elimate - No LoA 2 for first stage
- Send CommonApp id (and Commit id) to CMU when they log in? Don't know.
- Won't use CommIT after get permanent credentials when they matriculate
- Why - CMU will raise LoA later, Should be able to use a campus id to
transfer once they are in HE. - Over time, CMU believes their id will be stronge
- Value
- Support costs
- No need to send out key for activation of permanent credentials.
- Using ID for Application process so with multiple sites
NCSU - Harry (Use Case #2) -
- persistent identity important
- No LoA 2 for first stage
- Need identifier mapping to reduce admin work on back end.
- Trust the CommIT Id more.
- Have a history and prior relationship that raise your level of confidence
PSU - Vince
- Matching of third-party information for applicants is most important
- (CommIT identifiers associated with SAT and ACT scores)
- Fed authn (Use case #2 - need to check with IAM folks)
- No LoA 2 for first stage (probably)
- Once they pay enrollment fees, then they would get PSU Access Account
Wisconsin - Karen/Keith
- Need to speak with Admissions
- Distance Ed/LoA 2 is most attractive - see large increase there
- LoA 2 is good for first stage, but LoA 1 would be helpful.
- Matching and duplicate records important
- Use CommIT to get a NetId.
- No need to send one time key to request NetId
Indiana - Mark
- Will add IU's use case to the wiki.
Basic Use Cases
--------------------------
- fed authn during admissions
- fed suthn to facilitate acquisition of final account
- matching for backend admin.
Levels of Assurance
-----------------------------
LoA 1 is standard; LoA2 is gravy.
- First stage - have person registry able to capture.